if at first you don’t succeed…


Recently, I have been seeing lots of pom pom hats.  Each time I think “Poms poms may be cute, but they are not for me.”  I don’t remember wearing them the last time they were in vogue, and I was younger and cuter then.  But I suppose my contrary nature got the better of me, because I saw a photo on Ravelry of an un-modelled hat with pom pom, made from The Uncommon Thread Lush Worsted (one of my favorite yarns) in Cobble (one of my favorite shades) with a beautiful, soft, fluffy (and very large) alpaca pom pom.  Within minutes, I had ordered the yarn and pom pom.  How does that happen?

Regular readers of this blog will know that my first attempt at this hat was a disaster, not because of any problem with the yarn or pattern but because I wasn’t paying attention.  (A little bit of stupidity was likely in play as well.)  The pattern, designed by Wooly Wormhead, and called Skelter, is completely lovely.  The stitch pattern is beautiful, and I love the way the decreases work into the crown:


Of course, you can’t see this beauty if you have a pom pom attached, but more on that in a moment.  The problem with the first hat was caused by not doing a gauge swatch and not using a tape measure.  With the second attempt, I kept the needle size the same (US6) but increased to the largest size (my head is big, but my gauge is also slightly under, so the result fits my 21″ head perfectly without being snug).  I knit 2″ of brim and then 5 pattern repeats before starting the decreases.  The completed hat used 66 grams of yarn (only 51 in the “teeny tiny hat” – my abortive first attempt).  If you use this yarn, please note that it can stretch quite a bit when it is washed; I was very careful to push it all back into the size I wanted before drying flat.  It is a gorgeous yarn, however, and lovely to knit with.  I knit this fabulous sweater with it a few years ago.

The brim of this pattern has a notch at the back; it turns out that it is perfectly placed for ponytail wearers:


Here is a funny but true tale.  Shortly after I ordered the supplies for this hat, I was passing though the Duty Free shop at Heathrow International Airport in London.  I saw the below hat, and just had to take a photo for you.  I draw your attention not so much to the hat, but rather to the price tag:


It’s a little hard to see, but the gist is: “Suggested price: £357, Our price £297.50, You save £59.50”  This cracked me up!  The GBP has taken a pounding in the last few weeks, but even at today’s less than stellar rates, this translates into dollars as “Suggested price $497, Our price $414, You save $83”.  I can hardly type this without giggling!  For my hat, I bought one skein of an extremely luxe hand-dyed yarn for £24 (of which I used .65 of a skein) and one pom pom for £8.  I happen to think mine is prettier too, but that is a matter of taste.

So now, the real question:  Pom pom?


Or no pom pom?


Pom pom?


Or no pom pom?


I can’t believe I’m saying this, but the pom pom is actually starting to grow on me!


12 thoughts on “if at first you don’t succeed…

  1. I like it with the Pom Pom as well. I’ve seen some that has used a push button to snap it on/off depending on what style they wanted at any given time. Maybe one way too both have the cake and eat it?

  2. it is beautiful both ways, but I do like the pom pom. The ponytail notch is great! I have knit hats with a slit for a pony tail, but never thought of a notch!
    As for the hat price – wow! I wonder if there are shoppers out there who would actually pay that? I find that the top price I can put on one and sell any is about $60… and I do a whole lot better selling in the $35 area. 🙂 I need to find that demographic!

  3. Pompom, very definitely!

    The price for that hat is just ridiculous – I once saw very simple hats in Switzerland for CHF 90,
    but this tops everything!
    Wonder whether the beads are actual seed pearls and the wool is qiviut? Handspun by vestal virgins on an island far, far away? Er.

  4. I love it! What a nice save. The pompom definitely adds panache, and the vent for the pony-tail? As a fellow pony-tail wearer, I wholly approve. It’s brilliant, in fact.

    I think 6 people in my knitting group knitted the same pattern (Natter by Kim Hargreaves), and when you figure in a pompom, 2 skeins of Kid Classic and 1 skein of KSH, you’re coming in at close to 75$. Like your Harrod’s hat, a hat similar to the Natter was seen at Holt Renfrew’s (Canadian version of Harrod’s) for something insane like $395.

    All that to say, knitting IS economical!

  5. I would say Pom Pom, but both versions look nice. Sometimes though, no matter how cute a pom pom might be, I find that it hides the very beautiful crown a hat may have (like in this case), and that is just a shame to the work been done!

  6. Pingback: This and that | Knitigating Circumstances

  7. Pingback: Lockdown Flashback #13 | Knitigating Circumstances

Leave a Reply