Colour fail

It is sadly true that ordering yarn over the internet, based on how it looks on your computer screen, is a gamble.  Sometimes you win, sometimes you lose.  Having just finished up two sweaters (the adorable baby sweater blogged here and the beautiful cardigan for Leah which I will highlight next weekend), I needed to cast-on a new project. I have wanted to  try Sparrow, the 100% linen yarn from Quince & Co. for quite some time. I have also been enjoying the linen tee shirt Sel Gris by Claudia Eisenkolb which I knit last August, and I have had my eye on another linen tee from her linen collection, Pimenton. Here is the pattern photo of Pimenton, which uses three colours of Sparrow linen:

Pimenton

© Claudia Eisenkolb

 

I believed this would be a quick knit and would produce a comfortable linen top which could be dressed up or down and thrown in the dryer to boot.  I spent a very long time looking at the available shades of Sparrow on my laptop, and ended up ordering Citron for the main colour and Maize and Pink Grapefruit for the contrast colours.  In my head, I was envisioning a zesty lime green, a vibrant yellow and a orange-y shade of pink.  What I got was very muted, pastel-y, desert tones, with a very pink “pink grapefruit” (you think I could have guessed from the name), a soft buttery yellow and a barely distinguishable (from the yellow) slightly green-tinged yellow.

Being someone who could live with denial (and having nothing else to knit at the time) I cast-on in the somewhat misguided belief that they would somehow transform themselves on the needle.  The pink continued to be pink:

P1000691

Adding the yellow did not help:

P1000700

Here you can see it alongside the swatch, which I knit in the green, which is supposed to form the body of the pullover.

P1000701

(These photos are proof of the inexact and fickle nature of colours on screen – none of these photos captures the shades properly; the yellow is closest in the middle photo, the pink in the last photo, and the green is actually much more muted and yellow-y than shown above).  This seriously wasn’t doing anything for me, though I continued to press ahead, firmly in denial-land.  It is not that these colours are not pretty in their way; it is just that they are definitely not “me”.  My friend Inge, not known for mincing words, saw me knitting it this weekend and said “Kelly, those colours are vile on you!”

The interesting and sad part of this story is that I originally ordered them over the internet because I believed that I would not have an opportunity to get into London to the yarn shop for a few weeks.  As chance would have it, I was in London on business a few days ago, and was able to make a very brief foray into Loop.  There, I saw a basket full of Sparrow linen, and I have to tell you that Sparrow comes in the most luscious, glorious shades.  I ended up buying six of them just because I couldn’t resist.

P1000703

These colours are so spectacular!  I couldn’t believe it: I loved every colour but the three which I ordered!  Major colour fail!

P1000707

I have decided to frog the Pimenton (perhaps to try again next summer), and I have not yet decided what to do with the six new shades.

In other colour news, just as I was leaving the house to rush into London, I received an email from Emma with a request for a sweater!  How serendipitous!  This was justification enough for a yarn-shopping detour in the city.  Emma wants me to knit her Tinder, a cardigan designed by Jared Flood of Brooklyn Tweed:

 

Tinder1_medium2

© Brooklyn Tweed/Jared Flood

I have always liked this cardigan and am happy to knit it for her.  She asked for a mossy green.  They had three greens in Shelter (Brooklyn Tweed’s worsted weight yarn): Tent, which I deemed too blue; Artifact, which I thought was too gloomy, and Birdbook, which is very olive.  I bought the Birdbook, which is really an army green shade, but since it is tweed, has bits of brighter tones – blues and reds and yellows.  I whipped up a swatch last night, and am all good to go, but I can’t stop fretting about the colour.  I really want to make sure that it is exactly what Emma wants before I knit it up (daughters can be very exacting)! I took a photo of the swatch, which shows off both the ribbing and the pretty pattern stitch: here it is, Emma!

P1000692

But, of course, a problem remains; in fact the very problem I stated at the start of this post. It is nigh impossible to guarantee the colour you see on your screen compares to the colour in real life.  So, I have come to the unfortunate conclusion that my best option is to send the swatch to Emma and let her make up her mind.

This means, sadly, that I am back where I started a week ago – with nothing on my needles!  Boo hoo.

5 thoughts on “Colour fail

  1. oh dear! I hope you find a use for the colors you have even if not altogether in one garment. Maybe some of them look nice with the blues? Meanwhile, you have a sampling of blues and grays that I think would look lovely in that – pick your three favorites and order them. 🙂 It will give you something to do while you await the green verdict. 🙂

  2. Since I don’t have a yarn store anywhere near me, I have to purchase all my yarn via the internet. What I’ve learned along the way is when I see colorways that I like, I look at them on at least 3 different sites. Usually I look at the colorways on the maker’s site, the store from which I am thinking of purchasing the yarn, and another store’s site or Ravelry. This helps decrease the number of surprises I get when the yarn arrives.

  3. Hi! I have had that problem with quince and co forever so that’s the only company where I buy color cards. I find it odd that for a company that prides itself on its photography that they don’t do a better job photographing their yarn. I’ve been disappointed in the colors more times than I can count. But when I see it in person, it’s a win! I do love their yarn

  4. Oh no – nothing on the needles?!? Catastrophe!! I can hardly imagine anything worse – poor you. Get thee off to your nearest yarn shop as quickly as possible – life is too short for knitting angst. Meanwhile, I completely sympathise with you about the colour issue. When one is keen to try different yarns not available in local shops, it becomes necessary to take a punt. But tricky given the price of better quality and indie yarns. It is also not always possible to obtain colour samples, is it. Perhaps technology will evolve to help with more accurate pictures. Sigh.

  5. I too am restricted to yarn purchase online – if I want Sirdar, Patons or Wendy then the yarn shops up here are fine but anything more exotic and I am left to trawl the internet. I have often promised myself a trip to Loop…

Leave a Comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s